| | Description | Price | S&H |  |
| #01 | #1: Ty Cobb - Detroit Americans | | Sold |
| #02 | #2: (Shoeless) Joe Jackson - Cleveland Americans | | Sold |
| #03 | #3: John Wagner - Pittsburgh Nationals | $1.00 each | $6 |
| #04 | #4: Christopher Mathewson - New York Nationals | $1.00 | $6 |
| #05 | #5: Walter Johnson - Washington Americans | | Sold |
| #06 | #6: Tristram Speaker - Boston Americans | | Sold |
| #07 | #7: Grover Cleveland Alexander - Philadelphia Nationals | | Sold |
| #08 | #8: Napoleon Lajoie - Philadelphia Americans | | Sold |
| #09 | #9: Richard Marquard - Brooklyn Federals | | Sold |
| #10 | #10: Conne Mack - Philadelphia Americans | $1.00 each | $6 |
| #11 | #11: John Evers - Boston Nationals | $1.00 each | $6 |
| #12 | #12: Branch Rickey - St. Louis Americans | | Sold |
| #13 | #13: Fred Clarke - Pittsburgh Nationals | | Sold |
| #14 | #14: Harry Hooper - Boston Americans | | Sold |
| #15 | #15: Zachary Wheat - Brooklyn Nationals | | Sold |
| #16 | #16: Joseph Tinker - Chicago Federals | | Sold |
| #17 | #17: Edward Collins - Chicago Americans | | Sold |
| #18 | #18: Mordecai Brown - St. Louis Federals | | Sold |
| #19 | #19: Edward Plank - St. Louis Federals | $1.00 | $6 |
| #20 | #20: Walter Maranville - Boston Nationals | | Sold |
| #21 | #21: John McGraw - New York Nationals | | Sold |
| #22 | #22: Miller James Huggins - St. Louis Nationals | | Sold |
| #23 | #23: Ed Walsh - Chicago Americans | $1.00 each | $6 |
| #24 | #24: Leslie Bush - Philadelphia Americans | $1.00 each | $6 |
